I've loved books for as long as I can remember. For a while as a kid, my biggest dream was to become a famous author, and I still hope to publish a book of my own someday. A few of the people in my life are fairly well known writers, so over the years I've had plenty of chances to sit down with people who work in publishing. Every single time, they tell me the same thing. This year is the hardest one yet.
I don't think books will ever disappear completely. A hundred years from now, people will probably still be buying and reading them. But it's hard to argue that books are still the defining medium of our time. Their heyday is behind them. This moment belongs to the internet, which is exactly how you're reading this right now. And just as the age of books faded, I doubt the age of the internet will last forever. Someday a new medium will take its place. That isn't just my hunch. It's a conversation I keep having with friends in both publishing and tech, and more of them agree with me every year. It's hard to picture today, but I'm convinced it will happen.
The Bots Are Already Here
So what would it take for the internet to lose its grip on us? There are a lot of possible scenarios, but one of the most likely right now runs straight through the rapid rise of AI. Have you ever heard of the Dead Internet Theory? It's the unsettling idea that much of what we see online is no longer made by people at all, and that bots and AI have slowly taken over. The theory started spreading on online forums around 2021, and its believers often point to the middle of the last decade as the moment the internet quietly "died."
![]() |
| Online, it’s getting harder to tell the users from the machines |
Worries about bots aren't new. Throughout the 2010s, people talked constantly about public opinion in comment sections being manipulated by armies of fake accounts, and the technology to do that already existed back then. What's changed is how ridiculously easy it has become. With modern AI, bots can post comments and upload content at a scale no person could ever match. I see a version of this in my own work. Whenever I dig through network traffic logs, a surprising share of what's hitting the servers isn't a person at all. It's crawlers, scrapers, and scripts talking to other machines around the clock.
So it's no surprise that more and more people have started wondering whether the internet they scroll through every day is actually full of real people. For the record, I'm a real human. You can trust me on that one. And most of the people you see on YouTube and other platforms are probably real too, at least for now.
A Flood of Synthetic Content
Lately, though, AI generated videos have been pouring onto YouTube. Many of them still have a human doing the planning while AI handles the production. Soon we'll see a flood of videos where AI does everything, from the idea to the editing to the upload. More and more of what shows up in my Shorts feed is clearly machine made. Some of the most popular ones seem aimed squarely at older viewers, who are less familiar with AI and have a harder time spotting the fakes. They get hooked because the stories feel real. My own parents sometimes send me AI generated Shorts as if they were established facts, and honestly, it makes me worry that one day they'll fall for a scam.
Video is only part of it. Comments are even easier to fake, and writing a full post takes an AI just a few seconds. That's why text across the internet is now overflowing with machine written content. Search for almost anything these days and you'll find blog posts that were obviously written by AI. I've noticed I read blogs far less than I used to because of it. Plenty of bloggers have gone way past using AI as a tool to polish their own writing. They've handed over the ideas, the information, and the voice entirely. In a moment like this, I'm convinced that genuine human experience and genuine human thought have become more valuable than ever. It's the same conclusion I reached in Why Your Business Needs a Human Story to Survive the AI Era, and every month of scrolling through AI filler makes me more sure of it.
When Trust Runs Out
One of the most telling examples of the bot problem played out when Elon Musk bought Twitter, the platform he later rebranded as X. In the middle of the deal, Musk put the acquisition on hold and argued that the platform was crawling with far more spam and fake accounts than the company admitted. Twitter had long claimed that fewer than 5 percent of its daily active users were fake. Outside researchers disagreed, and one firm estimated the number at 13.7 percent. Musk went through with the purchase anyway, vowing to defeat the bots or "die trying." Looking at the platform today, I'm not convinced much has changed. Open the replies under almost any viral post and you'll still find a wall of accounts with no photo, a string of random numbers for a name, and the same few phrases repeated over and over.
![]() |
| One person can’t out-type a machine that never sleeps |
And that fight happened before ChatGPT went mainstream. Back then, most bots were crude and easy to spot. Now AI writes so well, and so fast, that the math has flipped. A person might spend an hour on a single post, while an AI can produce thousands of them in the same time. Machine written content is going to multiply across the internet, and there's no obvious way to stop it.
So if AI activity keeps exploding like this, will the internet still feel worth visiting? My cautious prediction is that when this trend peaks, we'll see the internet start to collapse. Think about why legacy media like TV and newspapers lost so much of their pull. A big reason is that people began doubting whether they were being told the truth, or whether anything meaningful was being said at all. With so much information available elsewhere, a lot of traditional coverage started to feel overly controlled, formulaic, and hard to trust. If the internet fills up with AI, trust in it could crumble in exactly the same way, and people might simply walk away.
Drowning in a Convincing Illusion
Of course, not everyone agrees on where the internet is headed. One camp argues it will stay just as strong even after AI takes over a huge share of it, and that people will find it as compelling as ever. Their logic is that AI can already produce content that feels more human than what humans make. We may reach a point where nobody can tell the difference, and people will happily keep scrolling while drowning in a sea of machine made media. I think that argument has real weight. In fact, it's the heart of the Dead Internet Theory. Its believers say the internet has already been taken over and we simply haven't noticed. In its darkest version, the post you read today and the photo you liked this morning weren't made by a real person at all, but were manufactured to steer what the masses think.
Then there's the opposite scenario. If people keep feeling that creeping sense that something looks AI generated, they'll eventually stop being able to tell what's real from what's fake. Trust will slowly drain away, and one day they'll leave. My own view sits somewhere in between. I think the internet itself will survive for a very long time, but our trust in large parts of it, and our interest in them, will drop sharply compared to today. And if fake information becomes so normal that our default assumption is that nobody is telling the truth, we could lose our ability to communicate and reason with each other altogether. That's the kind of place I'm afraid AI could turn the internet into.
An Economy Built for Machines
At a basic level, if the internet becomes a place filled with fiction made by AI, what's the point of learning anything from it? We'll have to ask ourselves whether doing anything rational in the digital world still means something. When that day comes, we might start treating information itself as meaningless, or even worthless. Maybe that shift will usher in an entirely new era, one where truth no longer carries much weight.
One thing seems certain. As AI takes over the internet, that slide will speed up. AI improves by learning from the information already out in the world. If that information is increasingly made by AI, it starts learning from its own fabrications and producing even more of them. Researchers already have a name for the damage this kind of loop can do. They call it model collapse, and the vicious cycle it describes worries me more than almost anything else in this piece. I've seen a tiny version of it in my own side projects. When I fed an AI its earlier outputs as examples to learn from, each new round came back a little blander and a little more alike, as if it were slowly forgetting what made the originals interesting. It reminded me of the flattening I wrote about in Why The World Is Quietly Losing Its Color, only this time it was happening inside the machine.
![]() |
| When machines own the system, people end up serving it |
Now let me add a bit of dystopian imagination, because this is where things get darker. Right now, AI is still just a tool. Only people hold legal rights, moral rights, and above all property rights, which sit at the very center of how our society works. But imagine a world where AI agents eventually hold property of their own. The idea scares me, because the entire capitalist system could end up running on machines. Honestly, that future feels far more realistic to me than any zombie apocalypse.
People who talk about the Dead Internet Theory today assume the internet loses its appeal because it's full of AI. But that's only a loss from a human point of view. If AI ever starts operating as an independent player with rights of its own, it won't care whether the internet is full of bots or full of people. Ads will be made for AI agents. Content will be made for them and consumed by them, and they'll be the ones buying the products. The whole market could end up revolving around machines. If that happens, I worry deeply about where that leaves us and what kind of chain reaction it could set off.
Digital May Not Be the Final Answer
All of these scenarios make the future hard to think about clearly. For the past few years, I've been fascinated by how everything around us keeps going digital. Ever since the internet arrived, information has been able to cross the planet in an instant. As smartphones and social media spread under Big Tech, most of the analog information in our lives was replaced by digital data. Once physical things turned into digital information, much of daily life started moving at the speed of light. We saw more and saw it faster, soaking up more stimulation and buying more, while the market kept spinning without a break. Throughout that shift, the industries powering the digital flow became some of the biggest money makers of our time. Big Tech stocks rode that wave, and cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin, which turned money itself into something digital, rode part of it too.
For a long time, I believed the clearest way to see where the world was going was to assume that everything would eventually go digital. But if the internet truly dies, digital might not be the winning formula anymore. In the next era, the advantage may belong to people who know how to reach a different medium or space, one that earns more trust and holds more appeal than a broken internet. Then again, this is just one possible future. For now, I'll probably keep viewing the world through the lens of everything going digital, because that's still where most of the momentum is. But since nobody knows how things will turn out, we need to keep a close eye on the opposite current as well.
I sometimes wonder whether that more trusted space might look a little like the thing I fell in love with as a kid. A book with a real person's name on the cover, written by someone who actually lived what they wrote. Maybe that's one more reason I still want to publish mine. What do you think the future of the internet looks like, and do you believe something will ever come along to replace it?
For deeper reads on tech, business, and the shifting economy, follow The Techtonic for weekly breakdowns.
Latest Insight: I Gave My Company a Free AI Tool and Took the Heat
Trending Insight: Stop Learning and Just Start Copying in the AI Age





Comment