I was watching the news the other night when the US midterm results came on, along with nonstop coverage of what they meant for Trump. I've never been especially into politics, but that night stuck with me. I usually keep my political views to myself. Talking about politics or religion online is one of the fastest ways to lose half your readers, so I've mostly stayed away from it here. But that broadcast made me want to finally say something I've been sitting on for a long time. Don't worry, I'm not about to tell you who to vote for. What I want to talk about is the enormous effect politics has on the way all of us live.
Back when I was in college, there was a federal election here in Australia. I had a friend who had zero interest in politics. I wasn't particularly interested either, but I at least turned up and voted. Voting is compulsory in Australia, so he couldn't skip it entirely. He told me he'd get his name crossed off, drop a blank ballot in the box, and grab a sausage from the barbecue they run outside almost every polling place here. I asked him whether it wouldn't be better to actually pick someone. He answered with what's sometimes called the paradox of voting. One vote, he said, wasn't going to change anything. Next to millions of other people, his single ballot was almost nothing, so why should he bother pretending it mattered? I remember being completely thrown by that question. I didn't take it very seriously back then, but the older I get, the more I understand exactly what he was getting at.
Why One Vote Feels Pointless
Honestly, I think there are more people who feel the way my friend did today, not fewer. Most of us are busy just getting through the day. Even if I cared deeply about politics, carefully picked out the genuinely good politicians, and threw all my support behind them, how much would that actually change? Does watching the news every night really make me better at spotting a good politician? And since I can only vote for whoever ends up on the ballot anyway, is there even one truly good person on that list? Doubts like these keep creeping in, and I find it hard to land on any solid answer.
That's a serious problem. Politics has shaped human life from the ancient world to today. Society can't function without it, and politicians are still handed huge amounts of power by design. If ordinary people lose interest at a moment like this, if politics starts to feel dull and they can't find a shred of hope in it, our future gets a lot darker.
The Precariat Can't Unite
![]() |
| Byung Chul Han says the workers who once united now compete alone |
I've been reading Byung Chul Han, a philosopher born in Seoul who has spent his career in Germany. He isn't my favorite writer, but his book The Transparency Society left a real mark on me, and I think his work explains better than anything why caring about politics has become so hard. Han argues that we no longer live in the age of the proletariat but in the age of the precariat. Think back to the working class of earlier centuries. They could unite around a shared ideal, and that's exactly how they managed to spark political revolutions. Their motives weren't purely noble, of course. But they came together and built serious power around a shared belief that things couldn't go on like this, that something was badly wrong, and that a better alternative was out there.
Today's precariat is different. Each of us is on shaky ground alone. Just making a living is hard enough, and we're stuck competing with everyone around us to stay afloat. A society built around achievement pushes people to keep chasing bigger results, treats results as the most important measure of a person, and makes everyone compare themselves to everyone else. That isn't all bad, and the world has clearly advanced because of it. But somewhere along the way, every one of us ends up isolated. I see it in my own life. Between my day job and the projects I work on at night, I spend far more time measuring myself against strangers online than thinking about anything we might have in common. Han argues that competition and division are now so deeply rooted in our minds that we can no longer come together around a shared ideal.
That's why politics struggles to show its strength. For politics to have real force, enough people have to unite around a common ideal, focus their energy on one point, and pour it into one person who can carry it. But when everyone is scrambling to survive on their own, gathering power like that is much harder than it used to be. I think he's exactly right about this.
A World Without Shame
Han makes another point I find fascinating. As I read him, he sees ours as a society where shame has disappeared. Shame happens when you accept that some higher value exists and realize you're falling short of it. If there's a moral ideal, something a person is supposed to protect, you feel shame when you know you're failing to protect it.
His argument here is subtle. People today have to fight constantly just to be recognized, so deep down many of us believe we aren't worthy of respect simply for being who we are. If respect only comes with big achievements, our sense of our own worth starts to collapse. And when that sense is this low, you can't afford to admit that any higher value even exists, because the moment you do, you become even smaller in your own eyes. I'm already anxious about looking like a failure and losing what little recognition I have. If I admit those higher values are real and that I don't measure up to them either, I won't know where to find my worth at all. So when someone holds up a higher value, people react defensively and push back hard.
Where the Public Sphere Went
There's one more argument of his that I agree with completely. Han says the public sphere has badly decayed. The public sphere is the space where people talk about shared public questions, and he argues there are hardly any people left who know how to carry that kind of conversation. The easiest way to see this is to compare the eighteenth century with today. Drawing on the sociologist Richard Sennett, Han points to the coffeehouses of eighteenth century Europe, which grew into a real public sphere. People who gathered there didn't need to share their personal opinions, talk about their private lives, or reveal their deepest feelings. Talking about a common public topic was enough to carry the conversation.
![]() |
| Stepping into public once meant putting on a costume and playing a part |
In that world, Han says, everyone lived a bit like a stage actor. Actors have private lives, but the moment the curtain rises, they put on the costume and speak the lines the stage calls for. People back then lived their private lives too, but the moment they stepped into public, they put on a different persona, usually dressed up, and spoke as if they were performers on a stage.
By the nineteenth century, that started to change. Public life moved into bigger halls and theaters where audiences learned to sit quietly and listen, and most people were reduced to passive spectators. In the coffeehouse, almost everyone had the right to speak. Each person stepped onto the stage and addressed the room with a public opinion, not a private one. In the new, larger venues, the speaker at the front was cut off from everyone else, and the crowd was pushed into simply listening. The topics shifted toward private matters too.
Han argues this only got worse with television, a system that keeps almost everyone in a completely passive role. What strikes me as most important is that we lost the chance to practice how to act in public and what it actually means to take part in public conversation. I suspect this is tied to how many shared rituals have faded from modern life, something Han writes about in The Disappearance of Rituals. Showing up to weddings and funerals, where everyone follows a shared public form in front of others, may have done a lot more to hold the public sphere together than we realized.
Then the internet arrived, and I think something big changed. People got their voice back. Nobody has to be a passive spectator anymore, and anyone can say what they want. The problem is that most of us only ever talk about our private lives. When private opinions and private feelings take over almost everything we say, the public sphere collapses in a whole new way. Maybe that's because we were handed the right to speak without ever getting the chance to practice what to say in public and how to say it.
The closest I've come to that old coffeehouse feeling was a Saturday not long ago, when I ended up in a room with people from a handful of different companies, arguing about who should actually own the AI agents a business puts to work, the same question I'd been chewing on in Nobody Is the Parent of Your Orphaned AI Agents. Nobody talked about their feelings or their personal lives. We argued about a shared problem, disagreed out loud, and left better for it. It was one of the best conversations I'd had in months, and it made me realize how rarely that happens anymore.
Moments like that are why I still think the internet has huge potential and could be the perfect place for public conversation. But because most of us never got that practice, it hasn't become a true public sphere.
What Comes After Politics
When I really think about all this, I've started to wonder, cautiously, whether the age of politics might be over. The story we always pictured, where a great leader rises, people rally behind them, the world gets better, and a big fight is won, may be finished, simply because real unity has become so hard. Does that mean we're headed for a dystopia? Will the world fall into chaos? I honestly think we'll have to wait and see.
My own guess is that whatever comes after the age of politics might be an age of religion. That's a strange thing to hear from someone who doesn't believe in God, I know. I've already seen hints of it in Why People Are Turning AI Into A New Religion, where I looked at people starting to treat AI with something close to faith. But if people really are being crushed by the pressure of an achievement society, and that crushed sense of worth sits at the root of so many problems, then the only lasting fix might be planting one idea in people's minds. The idea that you deserve respect simply because you exist, and that your worth has nothing to do with what you achieve. I think religion is almost the only thing that has ever pulled off something that big. Whether it's a traditional faith, a new movement, or something so different that nobody even calls it a religion, I can't say. But religion has always had a powerful way of holding an idea and using it to move huge numbers of people. So I can picture a future where spiritual leadership shapes whatever world comes next. I just hope whoever ends up leading spreads genuinely good ideas.
Nobody Has a Place to Talk
I also think teaching people how to express their views is going to matter enormously. How well can we make our case in online spaces and in whatever new forums this era creates? Can we get past our private feelings and talk seriously about what we think, as people who share a society with everyone else? I mean the questions that aren't only about me, the ones that affect all of us. How well we learn to discuss those questions, share real ideas, and push back on each other will be one of the most important parts of how we raise the next generation.
I honestly don't know how much I can do to help build a real public sphere. But one feeling keeps coming back to me lately. Even people who think deeply and wrestle seriously with a subject have no idea where to go to actually talk about it. I hear it all the time, because people come to me with exactly that frustration.
I feel it myself too. I think about AI constantly and in a lot of depth, but when I bring it up with friends or family, nobody really engages. A few sentences in, I can see their eyes glaze over. Whether it's a hard question about life or a serious thought about society, I believe the lack of a proper place to have those conversations is one of the biggest social problems we have. How we build those places will shape a great deal of what comes next.
That's what I want this blog to be, a small coffeehouse where we can actually talk.
For deeper reads on tech, business, and the shifting economy, follow The Techtonic for weekly breakdowns.
Latest Insight: Why Being a Little Pretentious Is Good for You
Trending Insight: Why Using AI Well Is No Longer Enough to Survive




Comment